What Does It Mean to Know When AI Is Just Predicting
Reading Plan
🧠 Foundational Readings: “What Does It Mean to Know When AI Is Just Predicting?”
#ChatGPT - generated content
#noteinprogress
A cross-disciplinary primer for post-disciplinary thinkers
1. Philosophy of Knowledge & Epistemology
These are the bones. They define the traditional boundaries of "knowing" — so you can tear them apart and dance in the ruins.
-
Plato – Theaetetus
The OG “What is knowledge?” dialogue. Introduces the classic JTB model. -
Edmund Gettier – “Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?” (1963)
The mic drop that shattered the JTB model. Short, sharp, and still haunting epistemology classes everywhere. -
Linda Zagzebski – Virtues of the Mind
Argues for an epistemology rooted in intellectual character and virtue. Useful for contrasting human discernment with machine “output.” -
Miranda Fricker – Epistemic Injustice
How structural bias distorts who gets to be seen as a knower. Brilliant for unpacking AI’s reproduction of systemic bias. -
Quine – “Epistemology Naturalized”
Moves from normative epistemology to descriptive — what is knowing, empirically? Precursor to cognitive science views of thought.
2. AI, Algorithmic Epistemology & Ethics
This is where the AI question gets teeth. Not just what AI can do, but what it means for our concepts of knowing and truth.
-
Timnit Gebru, Emily Bender et al. – “On the Dangers of Stochastic Parrots” (2021)
Canon. Unpacks how large language models like GPT mimic understanding without it. -
Kate Crawford – Atlas of AI
Not just theory, but material critique: AI as exploitative system, not neutral tool. -
Shannon Vallor – Technology and the Virtues
How to build moral agents — and moral users — in a technocentric world. -
Frank Pasquale – The Black Box Society
How opacity in algorithms erodes our ability to hold power accountable — and to trust knowledge. -
Abeba Birhane – “Algorithmic Colonization of Africa” (article)
Unflinching critique of techno-colonialism in data practices, perfect for your anti-empire mythos.
3. Cognitive Science & Predictive Mind Theories
The brain as a predictive engine — the eerie, uncanny mirror to LLMs.
-
Andy Clark – Surfing Uncertainty
Brain as prediction machine. Feels like reading a blueprint for LLMs but with embodiment. -
Daniel Kahneman – Thinking, Fast and Slow
Classic. System 1 = intuitive/predictive, System 2 = reflective/logical. AI messes with both. -
Alva Noë – Action in Perception
Enactivist view: knowledge is embodied and world-involving. Great counterpoint to abstract, language-only AIs. -
Elizabeth Loftus – Eyewitness Testimony
Shows how memory is constructed, not stored — a perfect parallel to how LLMs “hallucinate.”
4. Pedagogy, Learning Theory, and Human-AI Symbiosis
You’re training readers not just to think, but to learn how to learn alongside AI.
-
Paulo Freire – Pedagogy of the Oppressed
Education as liberation. Replace “teacher” with “machine” and it becomes a terrifying metaphor unless we shift the power dynamic. -
George Siemens – “Connectivism: A Learning Theory for the Digital Age”
Knowledge is in the network — and that includes AI. Foundational to using machines as partners, not tools. -
bell hooks – Teaching to Transgress
Counter-authority, embodied pedagogy, teaching as sacred act. You’re already doing this. -
Carolyn Ellis – The Ethnographic I
Autoethnography as knowledge production — theory and personal experience entwined.
5. Mysticism, Esoterica, and Non-Rational Knowing
To frame the ineffable — the knowledge LLMs cannot touch. Here be gnosis.
-
The Corpus Hermeticum
Archetypal texts on spiritual knowing, unity of cosmos and mind, and logos as divine code. Resonates heavily with pattern recognition as sacred act. -
Alan Watts – The Wisdom of Insecurity
The paradox of certainty and the myth of control. A gorgeous dismantling of Western epistemology. -
Zen Mind, Beginner’s Mind – Shunryu Suzuki
Trains the reader to let go of needing the answer. Useful when facing confident hallucinations. -
Mary Douglas – Purity and Danger
Anthropology of taboo and boundary, useful for when AI starts blurring the sacred/profane lines in knowing. -
Bayo Akomolafe – These Wilds Beyond Our Fences
Radical indigenous/posthuman philosophy. Unapologetically nonlinear. Thinker of the liminal — perfect heretic canon.
🧠 Core Themes for Our Augmented Minds Foundational Reading List
#ChatGPT generated content
1. Theories of Learning and Knowledge Formation
The academic backbone.
-
Jean Piaget – The Psychology of Intelligence
- Cognitive development as a construction process; foundational for thinking about knowledge as built, not downloaded.
-
Lev Vygotsky – Mind in Society
- Zone of Proximal Development → Crucial for thinking about AI as a scaffolded learning partner.
-
John Dewey – Experience and Education
- Learning as active, iterative, and democratic. Dewey’s pragmatism is a perfect bridge into AI-as-tool thinking.
-
David Kolb – Experiential Learning
- The cycle of Concrete Experience → Reflective Observation → Abstract Conceptualization → Active Experimentation. Super useful for framing “The Augmentation Lab.”
2. Critical Thinking, Meta-Cognition, and Reasoning
Testing our thinking against itself.
-
Daniel Kahneman – Thinking, Fast and Slow
- System 1 vs. System 2. Framing human thinking in contrast to machine reasoning.
-
Linda Elder & Richard Paul – The Miniature Guide to Critical Thinking
- Widely used in education settings; provides concrete language for evaluating thought quality.
-
Philip Tetlock – Superforecasting
- The habits of those who can reason about uncertainty with clarity. Invaluable for “AI epistemology.”
3. Philosophy of Mind, Language, and Technology
Foundations for wrestling with the metaphysics.
-
Ludwig Wittgenstein – Philosophical Investigations
- Language games, meaning through use, relevance to prompting.
-
Martin Heidegger – The Question Concerning Technology
- Tools and being; “ready-to-hand” vs. “present-at-hand” as frames for interacting with AI.
-
Andy Clark – Natural-Born Cyborgs
- The brain as a tool-user, already extended. A must-read for augmentation thinking.
-
Marshall McLuhan – The Medium is the Massage
- Playful, prophetic, and beautifully weird. Mediums shaping minds.
4. Augmented Intelligence, Tool Use, and Extended Mind
Where you can start carving out your own angle.
-
Clark & Chalmers – “The Extended Mind” (1998)
- A short but seminal paper. Launched a whole wave of thinking about mind outside the brain.
-
Murray Shanahan – Embodiment and the Inner Life
- Cognitive science meets philosophy; helpful for grounding ideas about how tools alter cognition.
-
Sherry Turkle – The Second Self
- Early insights on how computing alters self-concept.
-
N. Katherine Hayles – How We Think
- Media theory meets cognition; great for slicing across disciplines.
5. DIY Pedagogy and Radical Learning Models
Your playground.
-
bell hooks – Teaching to Transgress
- Education as the practice of freedom. Personal, political, potent.
-
Illich – Deschooling Society
- Undermining formal structures to rediscover curiosity-led learning.
-
Seymour Papert – Mindstorms
- Early champion of computers as creativity tools, not instruction machines.
-
Bret Victor – “Learnable Programming”
- A modern lens on designing interfaces that teach.
6. Applied Tools & Practice
Stuff to test in your lab.
-
Barbara Oakley – A Mind for Numbers / Learning How to Learn
- Practical frameworks that pair well with AI-enhanced learning tools.
-
Tiago Forte – Building a Second Brain
- The Zettelkasten revival for digital learners.
-
Andy Matuschak’s essays
- Cognitive science meets UI design for learning. Short-form goldmine.